The Classroom Bookshelf
Inside The Classroom Bookshelf

Trapped: How the World Rescued 33 Miners from 2,000 Feet Below the Chilean Desert

Trapped: How the World Rescued 33 Miners from 2,000 Feet Below the Chilean Desert
Written by Marc Aronson
Atheneum, New York
 ISBN: 978-1-4169-1397-9
Grades 5-8
Book Review
Written in the two and half months following the rescue of the Chiean miners in October of 2010, this book is like a newly dug mine: deep, rich, but with an expanse one might not expect by simply looking at the entrance. Drawing from geology and plate tectonics as well as Greek mythology, in particular, Hephaistos, the oft-neglected blacksmith to the gods, Aronson grounds his readers in a physical, historical, and socio-economic context in which to view the mine disaster. Next, we are launched into a running narration that covers actions above and below the ground as concurrently as one can in the fixed environment of print, capturing both the ways in which the miners “first saved themselves” and “[f]rom the bottom of the earth, they set an example for us” through their strength of character, to the ways in which disparate individuals, companies, and countries from around the world pulled together to rescue the trapped men. With just ninety-one pages of narrative, and another thirty-three pages of fascinating back matter, this trim volume is long enough to allow middle level readers to sink their teeth into it but short enough to allow for ample time to explore the text in a variety of classroom contexts before, during, and after reading. Young researchers and their teachers will particularly enjoy the essay “How I Wrote This Book,” the subtitle of which is “What I Learned That Could Be Useful for Students Writing Research Reports,” in which Aronson gets to the heart of how one has to have knowledge to gain knowledge, and how young researchers can build background knowledge, and allow for an ever-expanding list of questions to emerge as they conduct engaged research in the digital age.
Teaching Invitations
  • Who was Hephaistos? Throughout Trapped, Aronson refers to the much-abused Hephaistos, blacksmith to the gods of Ancient Greece. Using some of the digital and book resources listed below in Further Explorations, provide students with additional experiences with the story of Hephaistos. Once they have a sense of how he is portrayed, have them brainstorm other people, besides miners, who we treat in ways similar to the ways the Greeks treated Hephaistos.
  • Studying Survival. Trapped gives your students the opportunity to witness a modern-day real-life tale of collective survival. As Aronson notes, “first the miners saved themselves,” and then the world stepped in. Have students read nonfiction tales of survival, such as Nathaniel Philbrick’s Revenge of the Whale, a documentation of the real-life events upon which Herman Melville based his epic novel Moby Dick or Jim Murphy’s An American Plague, an account of how the citizens of Philadelphia  endured the yellow fever epidemic of 1793.
  • Researching Isolation. Have students compare and contrast the different ways that people stay healthy in mind and spirit while enduring rigorous conditions, small spaces, and almost utter isolation underwater, underground, and out in space.
  • Survival Short Stories. Before or after reading Trapped, have students read survivor fiction as well. They might choose from the bloody dystopian world of The Hunger Games trilogy (where mining plays an important role!) or classics such Jean Craighead George’s My Side of the Mountain, Gary Paulsen’s Hatchet, or Robert O’Brien’s post-nuclear Z is for Zachariah. After reading both fiction and nonfiction, have students create their own original short story in which a group of teenagers must survive on their own for a period of time. Have them consider the following questions as they research and write: How would they come together? Would conflicts might evolve? Who would surface as a leader? How would they cope with a lack of technology? Some students may prefer to write a narrative of another contemporary or historic story of survival, and research accordingly.
  • Using Math. Throughout the book, it is clear that basic math is essential in solving the problem of drilling down at appropriate angles to access and ultimately free the miners. Jeff Hart, who flew from Afghanistan to help the Chilean government, frequently speaks at schools, to talk about how he uses math. Math is not something “to get through because you have to. It is a language that allows people like him [Hart] to hit a target blind, thousands of feet away, to save lives, to bring water to our troops.” Collaborate with your team math teacher(s) to design a project in which students interview professionals in a variety of fields about the ways in which they use math as a tool for solving a problem or achieving a goal, concretely (like construction, mining, or manufacturing) or abstractly (like the financial industry, accounting, or social science research).
Critical Literacy
  • Mines in Everyday Life. Aronson informs us that “the average American uses sixteen pounds of copper a year – at home, at work, and at school.” At the end of the book, he cautions us that “[i]f we want the treasures of the Earth, we need to value our miners, not just when they are trapped by rocks, but whenever they enter the kingdom of the dark.” In have students research, small groups, products that are created using copper. Generate a class list, and have each student take a copy home to conduct an inventory. How many objects do they own or use that contain copper? To what extent does each of them depend on copper mines?
  • Good Mines, Bad Mines. If students are to “value the miners,” as Aronson suggests, is it possible to backtrack the source of copper in objects on the student-generated inventory? Provide students with the opportunity to research the origin of materials in one of the objects listed on their inventory. Is it possible to find out the source of materials? Where do they come from? What factories produce them? Is it possible to find out whether the copper came from a “good” mine with proper safety features, or a “bad mine,” such as the San Jose mine? Would this knowledge change what they buy? Why or why not?
  • Mine Safety in the US. How safe are US miners? Just months before the Chilean mine disaster, 29 coal miners were killed in an explosion at a West Virginia mine with a history of noted safety violations. Have students read the January 2011 Wall Street Journal article and the Mine Safety (see Further Explorations) about new proposed federal regulations for mine safety and determine if they have any evidence of the new regulations making progress towards making mines safer for workers.
Further Explorations

Online Resources

For your information, there is also a list of useful websites on pages 123-127 in the book.
Marc Aronson
CNN Coverage of Miners

October 2011 New York Times Article: One Year Later
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/10/12/world/americas/chiles-rescued-miners-face-major-struggles-a-year-later.html?_r=1&hp

View “the Rabbit” Drill from Center Rock Inc. Mining Company
Sterling Mine Museum, Ogdensburg, New Jersey
US Geological Survey Minerals Information (and maps)
US Environmental Protection Agency: Copper Mining in the US and Production Waste
January 2011 Wall Street Journal article on Federal Government Mine Safety Regulations
Mine Safety and Health Administration of the US Department of Labor
Hephaistos Overview
Books 
Bartoletti, S. C. (1996). Growing up in coal country. Boston: Houghton Mifflin.
  • A historic look at the anthracite coal mines of Pennsylvania in the 19th and early 20th centuries.
Collins, S. (2009). Catching fire. New York: Scholastic.
  • The second volume of the Hunger Games triology, which brings Catniss and Peter back into the Games.
 Collins, S. (2008). The hunger games. New York: Scholastic.
  •  The first in a dystopian trilogy that provides a snapshot of our nation’s fictional future, where our love of reality television and violence converge in a horrific annual ritual.
Collins, S. (2010). Mockingjay. New York: Scholastic.
  • The culmination of the Hunger Games triology.
 George, J. C. (1959). My side of the mountain. New York: Puffin.
  • A fictional tale of survival in the Castkill Mountains of New York State.
George, J. C., George, T. C., George, J. C.,  George, T. L. C. (2009). Pocket guide to the outdoors. New

York: Dutton.

  • A handy outdoor guide, written by children’s author Jean Craighead George and her adult children.
Murphy, J. (2003). An American plague: The true and terrifying story of the yellow fever epidemic of
1793. New York: Clarion Books.
  •  A riveting account of the yellow fever epidemic of 1793, and our new nation’s struggle with how to coordinate support services for its citizens.
O’Brien, R. (1973, 2007). Z is for Zachariah. New York: Simon Pulse.
  •  The story of young woman’s survival in the United States, after a nuclear war has caused much of the land surrounding her family farm to be contaminated, and the ominous arrival of a stranger.
Paulsen, G. (1987). Hatchet. New York: Atheneum.
  • Paulsen’s classic tale of teenage Brian, and his survival in the wilderness following a plane crash.
 Philbrick, N. (2002). Revenge of the whale: The true story of the whaleship Essex. New York: G.P.
Putnam’s Sons.
  • The real-life story of 19th century Nantucket sailors who stranded in the Pacific in small boats after an attack by a whale and resorted to cannibalism in order to survive. The accounts of survivors were used by Herman Melville to write Moby Dick.
Mary Ann Cappiello About Mary Ann Cappiello

Mary Ann is a professor of language and literacy at Lesley University. A former public school language arts and humanities teacher, she is a passionate advocate for and commentator on children’s books. Mary Ann is the co-author of Teaching with Text Sets and Teaching to Complexity.